Anton Rubinstein liked to announce that each tour would be his last. In June 1886 the Musical Times took that rumour with a pinch of salt and turned to the business at hand: seven “historical recitals” at St. James’s Hall, London, tracing keyboard music from its English beginnings onward. Berlin, the paper noted, had reportedly been given a dozen, and report credited the pianist with a joke about them: after twelve performances, he said, he “and might have added another made up of their wrong notes”.
The first evening, on 18 May, opened with Byrd’s “Carman’s Whistle” and Bull’s “King’s Hunting Jig”, passed through Couperin, Rameau’s clucking “La Poule”, Scarlatti’s “Cat’s Fugue”, Bach and Handel, and ended with Mozart’s Rondo alla Turca. That made thirty-seven pieces, for an audience “who emphatically had enough”. Three days later came eight Beethoven sonatas, from the “Moonlight” to Op. 111, which the critic thought far too much for a single sitting. Schubert, Weber and Mendelssohn filled the third evening.
The paper was not dazzled by everything. It reminded readers that Mr. Pauer and Mr. Bonawitz had given historical recitals before, and complained that the opening programme ignored the growth of the sonata. Even the feat of memory left it cool: “We attach little importance to the fact that every piece was played without book and without a slip.” At times the playing ran wild: ‘It was “pianism” of the convulsionary school, and more curious than beautiful.’
Yet the verdict was warm. In his gentler moods, the critic wrote, the very spirit of music seemed to animate him, and his secret lay less in finish than in his ability to absorb and convey the innermost qualities of the music. For the Musical Times he remained the foremost pianist of the day.
Sources: The Musical Times, 1 June 1886, “Rubinstein’s Recitals” (reporting the recitals of 18, 21 and 24 May 1886).