Second Only to Him: Paganini and His Imitators

November 11, 2026

When Paganini dazzled Europe, he also left its concert halls crowded with copies. In 1831 the Revue musicale heard a young violinist from Vienna, billed as M. Ernest, play solo variations in imitation of Paganini at a Paris concert. He had all the tricks: double stops, plucked notes, harmonics. The reviewer’s verdict, translated from the French, was that nothing was missing “except the intonation, the bow and the fingers of the famous violinist.” Another notice that year put it more simply: how far the copy was from the model.

London was kinder to Ole Bull in 1836. The Musical World called him “a close, and we presume a professed, imitator of Paganini,” but admitted that his imitations were clever enough to delight a cultivated ear. He had mastered the master’s difficulties, the paper decided, and “if Ole Bull is not quite equal to his exemplar, it is no slight praise to say that he is only second to him.” A week later it compared his rapid, even staccato to the pattering of a woodpecker.

Not every follower got off so lightly. In 1839 the Revue et gazette musicale mocked a M. Filippa, who called himself Paganini’s pupil, for believing that playing with one finger on one string was enough to follow in his footsteps.

By 1844 the mood had turned. A Manchester correspondent of the Musical World, who had heard Paganini many times, wrote that Ernst now excelled them all. He had “not the wild originality of Paganini,” the writer granted, but he had none of the trickery the writer found in Paganini and his imitator Sivori, and he used the great difficulties as ornaments rather than as the point of his playing. The age of the copy was giving way to the age of the artist.

Note: the French quotation is translated by The Musical Spectator.

Sources: Revue musicale, 1831; The Musical World, 3 and 10 June 1836 and 25 April 1844; Revue et gazette musicale, 1839.