Few phrases in music criticism have changed sides as often as “the music of the future.” Theodore Baker’s 1895 Dictionary of Musical Terms gave the standard story. Zukunftsmusik was “a term first used (according to R. Wagner) about 1850, by Dr. L. Fr. Chr. Bischoff, in a satire on Wagner’s essay” on The Art-work of the Future. Wagner’s admirers, Baker added, then adopted the jibe as a badge of honour: music with a future.
The truth is messier. In 1909 Le Ménestrel reported that the musicologist Wilhelm Tappert had found the phrase in an 1847 Berlin music paper, aimed not at Wagner but at Berlioz and his “musical hocus-pocus that is called the new music or else the music of the future” (translated). The same article noted that Schumann had written of future music as early as 1833, without any sneer at all.
By the 1850s it was everywhere. In 1854 a Musical World correspondent sailed down the Rhine with German critics who argued the whole way, some of the old school and some disciples of the School for the Music of the Future. That November the elderly Spohr wrote to an admirer, in a letter Le Ménestrel later printed, thanking him as one of those friends of art who did not expect their salvation from the music of the future.
Rossini, as reported second-hand in the Musical World of 1857, was more relaxed. Hearing German newspapers read to him in 1856, he is supposed to have said: “Thirty years ago, I should have been angry at the nonsense that is indulged in on the subject, but now I only laugh at it.”
Twenty years later the Musical Times could still speak of what was “absurdly termed the ‘music of the future’”. The future arrived anyway.
Note: the French quotation is translated by The Musical Spectator.
Sources: The Musical World, 22 July 1854 and 4 April 1857; The Musical Times, 1 November 1877; Theodore Baker, A Dictionary of Musical Terms (1895); Le Ménestrel, 30 October and November 1909.