In June 1890 the pianist M. Sapellnikoff advertised a second recital at St. James’s Hall in London, with Madame Sophie Menter joining him. The notice in The Musical World gave the prices in one short line: “Prices, 10s. 6d., 3s., and 1s.” That meant half a guinea for the best seats and a shilling for the cheapest.
For the performer, the sums ran the other way. The Musical Times listed what a concert-giver had to pay for: the hire of the hall, advertisements and programmes. Its verdict was blunt: “Work them out how one pleases, such concerts, in nineteen cases out of twenty, can only result in dead loss to the concert-giver.” Even a full house of paying listeners would rarely cover the costs, and many seats were given away to critics, friends and fellow musicians. The paper passed on a joke that “the tribe of pianists eked out a precarious livelihood by attending each other’s concerts”.
So why give recitals at all? Because a recital was really an advertisement. A young pianist played to be heard by the critics and the experts, whose opinion persuaded agents to offer paid engagements. The paper even suggested that recital-givers form a kind of trade union, share one hall, and start at noon with a break for lunch.
At the very top, the money looked quite different. If the newspapers were right, Adelina Patti’s American managers were paying her a thousand pounds a night, and a manager was said to be paying the twelve-year-old Otto Hegner eighty pounds for each appearance. Small wonder that The Musical Times had already written, in 1889: “The only way to make Concerts pay, as we heard it cynically remarked the other day, is not to pay your performers.”
Sources: The Musical World, 14 June 1890; The Musical Times, 1 December 1889, 1 January 1890 and 1 August 1891.