In the spring of 1877 Johannes Brahms finally had a symphony, and England heard it while the score was still unpublished. Its first English performance came at Cambridge on 8 March, on the day the university made the violinist Joseph Joachim a Doctor of Music. Brahms had been invited too, but he stayed at home. A London orchestra came down specially, and the symphony was played from manuscript.
The Musical Times sent a correspondent, who refused to give a verdict after one hearing. But he reported that the new work “sent the audience away with a consciousness that they had just heard for the first time music which the world will not soon let die.”
Three weeks later, on 31 March, the symphony reached the Crystal Palace at Sydenham under Mr. Manns. The same paper now called it “unmistakably one of the greatest symphonic works of modern times” and said that finer playing had never been heard even there.
The Philharmonic Society had announced the symphony as its great novelty, and gave what the paper called its first performance in London on 16 April. The playing fell short of Sydenham’s, and the hall stayed calm: “We cannot say that the reception of the composition was by any means enthusiastic; but then the English people are difficult to move.” By the summer the paper was openly sorry for the Society. Many subscribers had already heard the piece, and heard it better played.
The doubts lingered. When the Crystal Palace brought the symphony back a year later, the reviewer still warned that “Brahms’s style is too reflective, at times too abstruse, to meet with universal appreciation.” Yet he added that its signs of genius grew clearer with every hearing. London, it seems, needed more than one evening to make up its mind.
Sources: The Musical Times, 1 March 1877, 1 April 1877, 1 May 1877, 1 August 1877 and 1 May 1878.