Some honours arrive at exactly the wrong moment. Carmen opened at the Opéra-Comique on Wednesday 3 March 1875, and on the eve of the premiere Georges Bizet was made a knight of the Légion d’honneur. The Revue et gazette musicale reported the news with one dry line, here translated: “It would have been better to wait until the day after.”
Barely three months later the same paper printed his obituary. Bizet had died suddenly on a Wednesday evening at Bougival, of heart disease. Born in Paris on 23 October 1838, he was not yet thirty-seven, and the paper believed he would certainly have gone very far.
Carmen did not wait for him. When it reached the Monnaie in Brussels in early 1876, Le Ménestrel quoted the Guide musical’s careful verdict, here in translation: “The success had nothing of enthusiasm about it… but it was frank, spontaneous, unanimous.” Bizet’s music, the Guide explained, was too personal and too original not to unsettle at first a public used to well-worn formulas. In Vienna the Neue Zeitschrift für Musik reported a success that was striking, if not noisy.
London caught up in 1878. Carmen “is not exactly a new Opera, since its composer has been dead some two and a half years,” the Musical Times noted that March. When Her Majesty’s Theatre produced it in June, the same journal found it “quite refreshing to listen to music which possesses sufficient individuality to challenge criticism on its own account.” By August it was praising Minnie Hauk’s portrayal of the coquettish, cold-hearted gipsy.
Carmen went on to win its audiences city by city. Its composer saw none of it.
Note: the French quotations are translated by The Musical Spectator.
Sources: Revue et gazette musicale de Paris, March and June 1875; Le Ménestrel, early 1876; Neue Zeitschrift für Musik, 1875; The Musical Times, 1 March, 1 July and 1 August 1878.