A Monsoon of Acclamations: Jenny Lind as Amina

November 11, 2026

By the spring of 1848 Jenny Lind’s name was in the law reports as well as the opera columns. In February she lost a lawsuit in the Court of Queen’s Bench. Mr. Bunn, the plaintiff, said she had broken an agreement, made in January 1845, to sing twenty times at Drury Lane Theatre, including the part of Amina in Bellini’s La Sonnambula. The jury gave him £2,500 in damages.

Three months later she sang Amina anyway, opening her season at Her Majesty’s Theatre on 4 May. The Musical World ran out of weather to describe the second performance. After “Ah! non giunge” the curtain fell “in the midst of a hurricane of applause, and rose again for the encore amidst a whirlwind of cheers, and descended once more amidst a monsoon of acclamations.” The stage, the paper added, was strewn with flowers.

What moved people was not only the singing. When she took the opera on a provincial tour later that year, a Manchester critic, reprinted in the Musical World, wrote: “It is not so much acting as being Amina!” He went further: “It is the greatest compliment to Jenny Lind to say, that in her Amina we think and speak of her as the actress rather than the singer.” Her voice, he admitted, lacked the finish of Persiani and the sheer flood of Alboni, but dramatic truth came first.

Not everyone was swept away. In October a Glasgow correspondent, writing after a crowded night at the Theatre Royal, listed three objections. She made distracting stage business while another singer had his big air, she bid farewell to her lover with far too many curtsies, and she shook her head too hard in the great ensemble. Even the Nightingale, it seems, could be taken to task.

Sources: The Musical World, 26 February, 29 April, 13 May, 16 September and 7 October 1848.