Richard Wagner’s choice of a dignified little town for his great festival left people wondering, and Joseph Bennett of the Musical Times was not won over. “My own experience convinces me that scarcely could a worse selection have been made,” he wrote in September 1876.
The Revue et gazette musicale had warned its readers what to expect inside the theatre. It translated a note printed in the text of the Ring poem reissued for the festival: “the lighting of the hall will be reduced as far as possible, so that during the performance of the acts one will not be able to read the libretto.” Audiences were advised to study the poem beforehand, or during the intervals.
The cycles began, as planned, on Sunday 13 August. The Paris paper listed an audience including the German Emperor, the Emperor of Brazil and the King of Bavaria, though not all stayed to the end: the German Emperor left after Die Walküre. Bennett saw Wagner, in a dress coat and white tie, go down to greet the Kaiser. Liszt was there; Brahms and Joachim were not.
Outside the theatre, Bennett wrote, much spare time was spent fighting for food. Most performances began at four o’clock, after a hot walk along an unwatered road. And arguments were fierce: “the out-and-out Wagnerian is an intolerant person, not disinclined to use muscle as a means of conversion to the faith.” He reported sundry quarrels and at least one assault.
Six years later, for Parsifal, the Musical Times sent a correspondent back and found the opposite problem. Arriving after the patrons’ performances, he found the town wet and almost deserted: “nothing could exceed it in dreariness and melancholy.” He could choose almost any seat he liked.
Crowded or empty, Bayreuth was never ordinary.
Note: the French quotation is translated by The Musical Spectator.
Sources: The Musical Times, 1 September 1876 and 1 September 1882; Revue et gazette musicale de Paris, August 1876.